Womens Health Resources

Supported by:

  

 

Hormone Profiles  Menstrual cycle and performance

Importance of Quality Research

The gender gaps in science, medicine, and sport are well recognised and are unfortunately still real. Sport organisations and research institutions are working hard to bridge this gap, but the race to show progress can pose a significant risk to quality and meaningfulness of research.

Research on elite women’s sport has got much better and we have now reached the point where any research is no longer better than no research. Poor-quality research that risks misinterpretation is not progress. New technologies that overpromise and underdeliver are not good enough. Catchy but unsubstantial phrases - like “train women as women” - are not progress. Women’s sport should not be satisfied with only token efforts.

Trusted expertise, which is committed to the progress of women’s sport exists (for example, the Centre of Excellence for Women in Sport) and should welcome engagement and challenging questions from athletes and sport organisations.

How to tell if research can be trusted

Not all research is equal. A quick questionnaire to 12 people asking about feelings is nowhere near as good as well-designed scientific study covering 10,000 people carried out by a respected university with its findings published for review by other researchers.

As an athlete it’s best and easier to ask trusted sources like your coach, governing body, player association, UKSI, or a university to get their opinion on any new research or claims.

High quality research tends to

  • Be from an established university
  • Be published in a peer reviewed journal
  • Has a large sample size
  • Contains a comparison (control) group as part of the research
  • Be from researchers who are independent from the product being tested

Ovarian Hormone Profiles - not all sportswomen have a menstrual cycle.

The menstrual cycle is just one of many ovarian hormone profiles, which sportswomen may experience across their careers. Other examples of ovarian hormone profiles include hormonal contraceptives (e.g., the oral contraceptive pill, the contraceptive implant, the hormonal oil, etc.), pregnancy, menopause, and menstrual dysfunction (e.g., frequent or infrequent bleeding, no bleeding, no ovulation, etc.).

Athletes should receive education and training on your ovarian hormone profile, so you have adequate body knowledge to support your sporting needs.

Know your hormone profile

Athletes’ ovarian hormone profile should be regularly checked using objective measurements by a trained professional. These profiles cannot be established by using an app on your phone.

Ideally your club or sport will cover the costs of testing your hormone profile. Alternatively, your GP should be able to do some additional tests for free.

Monitoring your menstrual cycle

Most menstrual cycle tracking Apps are no better at keeping track of your periods than a diary where you mark bleeding and non-bleeding days to monitor cycle length. These Apps only track your periods and not your entire menstrual cycle. What they do offer is convenience, however many experts have real concerns about the use of period tracking Apps.

Specifically,

  • Apps cannot detect subtle menstrual dysfunctions
  • Too many Apps give poor-quality advice not backed by quality research
  • To many Apps use universal guidelines which are not suitable for all female athletes and can do more harm than good.             

Menstrual cycle phase based training and nutrition is not supported by research evidence.

There is no credible research evidence to support tailoring your training or diet to the phases of the menstrual cycle.

Despite its popularity in the media, especially social media, using menstrual cycle phase based training or nutrition is likely to hinder rather than enhance your development and performance. Your training and nutrition needs are better determined by your sport rather than your cycle.

Adjustments can be made to your training or diet in response to your experiences of the menstrual cycle if needed. For example, if you have adverse changes in your physical or emotional well-being, which limit your ability to train or fuel, your programme should be adapted to take this adversity into account.

However it is probably better to talk to your support team about making effective and appropriate interventions that minimise any physical or emotional changes. This should mean that you can fuel, train, and compete as desired and to the best of your ability on all days of the menstrual cycle.

For example, if you experience gastrointestinal distress (such as diarrhoea) during your period, you can make subtle changes in your diet to prevent this effect. Or if you experience anxiety in a particular phase, you can employ some psychological techniques to prevent this effect from happening or limit its effect in real-time.

There is no ‘high-risk’ injury phase of the menstrual cycle

Most injuries are due to a range of different things and the precise causes are difficult to identify, unless it is a collision/impact injury.

Relating injuries to menstrual cycle phase is an oversimplification for which there is almost no trustworthy research evidence. You are no more or less likely to get injured in one specific phase of the menstrual cycle.

Social media can be an echo chamber where you encounter opinions that agree with your own, but this does not mean that they are true. In science we say that “correlation does not mean causation”; this means that even though some female athletes have sustained an injury in the same menstrual cycle phase as other female athletes this does not necessarily mean that the menstrual cycle phase caused it.

When it comes to injury risk, you have no need to fear one phase of the menstrual cycle more than any other.

Competitions have been won on all days/across all phases of the menstrual cycle.

Your menstrual cycle does not solely dictate how you train, compete, or fuel or determine if and when you get injured. There is not enough credible data at present to support these views.

Medals have been won, and records set, across the entire menstrual cycle. With adequate knowledge of your own menstrual cycle and effective support and mitigation, there is no reason why you cannot train, compete, and fuel as desired. We must remember that not all sportswomen are affected by their menstrual cycle and that some sportswomen experience positive effects during their cycle.

Thankfully, menstrual cycles are no longer a taboo topic in sport; however, their potential impact should not be overstated. Instead, menstrual cycles, and other ovarian hormone profiles, should be embedded within the sporting environment using a pragmatic evidence-based approach.